Our Lady of Victory, [Est. 1868] 583 Throop Avenue at McDonough Street Brooklyn, N.Y. 11216 was my first elementary school. The property was sold many years ago. You could tell the church was a grand church for another time.
The church, which was designed by Mr. Thomas Houghton, cost $160,000 to complete, and contains many original and beautiful details. The white marble altar, also designed by Houghton, was a gift from the president of the Emigrant Savings Bank, James
McMahon; the tabernacle was given by Mrs. Cahill; the marble baptismal font was given by Dr .Sullivan. To ensure that he wouldn’t be outdone, the bank president also donated a solid gold chalice and a white silk cape “embroidered in rich designs.” The Stations of the Cross were made in Munich, and the painting and decorations were done by Baraldi, a famous painter based in Philadelphia. Six years later, in 1901, an elaborate new pulpit (since removed) was ordered from the Tiffany Glass and Decorating Company of Corona.
I don't know what occupies the building today or if it's still standing. The parish closed but the school was opened for sometime. The school was run by the Sisters of St. Joseph.
The church's 25-bed men's shelter, ''Our Father's House,'' - operated in a gray, granite former convent adjacent to the church - closed after serving more than 1,400 people since October 1974. 'The House Is Dying'.
2007 Three parishes in Bedford-Stuyvesant---Our Lady of Victory, Holy Rosary and Nativity of Our Blessed Lord/St. Peter Claver---have joined to become St. Martin de Porres parish, honoring the patron saint of interracial justice. The worship sites of this new merged parish remain Our Lady of Victory Church, 583 Throop Ave, Holy Rosary Church, 172 Bainbridge St., and Nativity/St. Peter Claver Church, 29 Claver Pl. The latter itself was formed by the merger of two parishes in 1973.